This is my real experience:
I haven't been a member of China Billion Business Alliance for a very long time. At the beginning, I was indeed attracted by the fact that I could get a 50 yuan referral bonus for each formal member I referred, which led me to join. Because I thought it only required an investment of 178 yuan, if it's true, I would just need to refer four people to break even. With a try-it-out attitude, I invested 178 yuan, downloaded the video tutorials, and gradually learned from them. I actually learned quite a few things. All the products sold there are from the company. Since you become a VIP member as soon as you join, you can freely act as an agent for all the company's products, which is a pretty good point.
Now I have nine formal members, haha, I've already broken even. And these nine members are working hard, bringing me a continuous stream of income. At first, it was a bit less, but as long as I persist, I believe earning 2000 yuan a month is not a dream. Earning 2000 yuan a month? Haha, my goal is relatively small. Let's achieve this one first before moving on to higher levels. The person who recommended me has already exceeded this number.
So I want to say here that China Billion Business Alliance is not a scam. Why do some people say it is? I went to check the posts they made about how they were scammed, and I came up with two points: First, some people who are eager for quick success joined China Billion Business Alliance and then used its name to deceive others everywhere, using sweet talk to lure people into joining and charging them a 50-yuan referral fee, then ignoring them afterwards without teaching them how to operate or make money. These people will definitely think that China Billion Business Alliance is a scam that collects referral fees for recruitment in pyramid selling. But what I want to say is that it's not China Billion Business Alliance that deceived you, but those who are eager for quick success and deceived you under the company's name. You cannot deny the whole company; the company is legitimate. If you joined China Billion Business Alliance but no one is helping you, you can contact me for help. My QQ numbers are 314044025 and 13178169. I am willing to teach you everything I know, just hoping that you won't say China Billion Business Alliance is a scam anymore because I feel it's really a good project after doing it. Second, those who joined China Billion Business Alliance but do nothing, just sitting around waiting for money. These people think that after spending 178 yuan and having their own website, the website will automatically generate money for them. After a while, when they find that their backend hasn't increased by even a cent, they start cursing China Billion Business Alliance as a scammer. Shouldn't they at least understand the situation before cursing? Unfortunately, there are quite a few such people.
Whether you joined but didn't make money, or you haven't joined but want to know the specific situation, you can add my QQ: 314044025, 13178169. I just want to contribute a little bit of effort.